| What the Critics said about the
ALLOY ORCHESTRA |
"An ominous low growl of gently teased percussion inaugurated the accompaniment to the rarely seen silent version of Hitchcock’s “Blackmail” (1929) in the first of three Alloy Orchestra appearances at the Winter Garden of the World Financial Center, on Wednesday night. This opening proved characteristic of a score that was evocative without being overstated and that followed the movie seamlessly. But with its shifting, eddying tides of sound, teasing out melodies from clarinet (Ken Winokur, the group’s director) or accordion (Terry Donohue) or synthesizer or percussion, the music could stand on its own. (The performance was taped for partial broadcast on WNYC’s “New Sounds Live,” a producer of the event, later this month.)
Beyond its evocative qualities — in, for instance, the frenetic, machine-sounding passages that accompanied scenes of turning car wheels and London traffic — the music reflected the brilliance of Hitchcock’s architecture. He plaited a thick rope of suspense from strands that initially seem inconsequential, and the music found and underlined these longer threads, creating and holding and intensifying a mood across multiple scenes, keeping one aware of the bigger picture. Yet it always stayed anchored to the action, seamlessly providing perfectly timed sound effects at telling moments: the ringing of a doorbell, the stabbing of a knife (here rendered as a shivering, metallic thinness)."
Anne Midgette, New York Times |
One of the groups most responsible for the renaissance in silent film musical performance is Alloy Orchestra, a Massachusetts-based group specializing in performing original accompaniments.
John Browniee.Wired Magazine
|
For thousands of audiences, it's been the Alloy Orchestra (today comprised of director Mr. Winokur, musician and vocalist Terry Donahue, and keyboardist Roger Miller) that has restored relevance to silent films."
S. James Snyder, NY SUN |
Cornell Cinema welcomes back the Cambridge-based Alloy Orchestra for another weekend of fabulous silent films and terrific original scores performed live by this three-man musical ensemble.
They have been performing their original scores for restored silent films since the early '90s and have emerged as the best, and best-known silent film accompanists in the world, each year premiering their latest work at the prestigious Telluride Film Festival.
Ithaca Journal |
| "It's was like both sides of my brain exploded," comment by a 10 year old audience member at Alloy showing of The General at the Kennedy Center in Washington DC. |
"The IT List" - 100 Most Creative People in
Entertainment...Telluride Film Festival faves, these Boston-based musicians
have rejuvenated the art of silent film with thrillingly quirky, percussive
scores."
Entertainment Weekly |
"Alloy Orchestra is revitalizing silent film
masterpieces with stunning new musical scores."
M.K. Terrell, Christian
Science Monitor |
| "Stoking the excitement (of the video
release of Strike) is the Alloy Orchestra... For Strike the tempo is kept
tightly coiled and pounding, which ...consistently adds fun to the deepening
pandemonium."
Peter M. Nichols, New York Times |
"It's rare to see silent films in 35mm and
this year's Telluride Festival offers some masterpieces... a restored version
of Sergei Eisenstein's 1924 debut film, "Strike," with live accompaniment
by the Alloy Orchestra, annual Telluride visitors who achieve an amazing
bandwidth of music and sound effects."
Roger Ebert, Chicago Sun-Times |
"...Sergei Eisenstein's shattering 1921 piedce
of agitprop "Strike" - in its take-no-prisoners style, arguably the most
violent movie ever made. The three piece Alloy Orchestra, specialists in
creating percussive music for revolutionary Soviet movies, augmented Eisenstein's
ripsaw editing with an original score."
Michael Sragow, San Francisco
Weekly |
"...Stirring score for Sergei Eisenstein's
"Strike," a beautiful, harrowing piece of anti-capitalist propaganda. The
power of this film was heightened by the clanking industrial rhythms of
this unique group of musical performers, and once again they were one of
the hits of the (Telluride) festival."
Ben Stephens, Sunday Camera |
"Thanks to the Alloy's stunning contribution, the
production (of Strike) is enhanced as never before. The orchestra helps
create a feel of palpable menace as factory workers' ire against the fatcat
factory owners builds to the breaking point. Whether underscoring the pop
of a champagne cork, a foundry's whistle or the graphic gutting of a bull,
they imbue every moment with its own unique sound and fury. By the time
the final clash of cymbals concludes a devastating finale, the mix of Eisenstein
and the Alloy has produced a spellbinding collaboration."
Larry Worth,
New York Post |
"Devastatingly poignant...Strike was filmed in 1924,
one of the great silent movies of its age. But after Alloy Orchestra performed
its scorching, thunderous score at yesterday's screening, it difficult to
believe the film ever existed without it. An energetic gem ... it was the
trio at its best."
Tristram Lozaw, Boston Herald |
| "The Alloy Orchestra from Boston, fast becoming
the country's leading avant-garde interpreter of silent films, is a half-quirky,
half serious outfit more than capable of adding extra menace to the long
bony hands and slow, malevolent gait of Murnau's vampire "(in Nosferatu).
Neil Strauss, New York Times |
"Strike, featuring live musical accompaniment
by the maestros of sproing-and-chunk grandeur, the Alloy Orchestra."
The
Nation |
"For the past seven years this ensemble's members
have made it their mission to reintroduce the silent era to the surround-sound
generation. The trio combines a percussive barrage (drums, hubcaps, truck
springs, and other found metal) with rich synthesized melodies."
Nathaniel
Moss, Vanity Fair |
"Alloy Orchestra is an extraordinary aesthetic salvage
act... Seeing The Man With the Movie Camera at the Castro with the Alloy
Orchestra is a genuine eureka experience."
Michael Sragow, SF Weekly |
"The new score (for Man with a Movie Camera) - written,
oddly, with clues from notes Vertov himself left - is unbelievable."
Susan
Gerhard, San Francisco Bay Guardian |
"Such music is not for the faint-hearted.
Its physicality in tandem with the dynamic films being presented on April
5 will make it difficult for the audience not to get physical too and jump
to their feet in a standing ovation. That is, if they can collectively catch
their breath."
John Morrison, The Valley Advocate |
| "A cinematic event of the highest magnitude...
the biggest- and best- addition is the Alloy Orchestra's glorious score,
(to Lonesome) which ranges from romantic reveries to rough-and-tumble re-creations
of Mother Nature's fury. Whether sounding a factory whistle's screech or
a calliope's enchanted outpourings, the Alloy's contribution is sheer magic
(as evidenced in their '95 accompaniment to 'Man with a Movie Camera.'"
Larry Worth, New York Post |
"The Alloy Orchestra created their magnificent score
(for Man with a Movie Camera). The music - imaginative and responsive, rhythmically
based, urban paced - makes the film a "talkie," and an audio-visual triumph."
Philip Elwood, San Francisco Examiner |
| "Amazing... when I saw this extravaganza (the Man
with a Movie Camera) at the 1,500 seat Castro movie palace in San Francisco,
the sold-out house handed it a five-minute standing O that would have gone
on if the staff hadn't had to clear the theater."
Michael Sragow, Seattle
Weekly |
| "Accompaniment is really an inadequate description
of the voodoo they do with their strange and wonderful repertoire of sonic
surprises."
Timothy Dugdale, Detroit Metro Times |
| "As virtuosic as Vertov's camera work (in Man with
a Movie Camera), as head-rushingly kinetic as the film's editing, as lavish
and overwhelming as a hundred-piece orchestra, the Alloy's music was a torrent
of modernist energy."
Gavin Borchert, Seattle Weekly |
"Performing their own scores to classic silent movies,
Boston's three-man (but truly symphonic) Alloy Orchestra have built a fervent
following by being just as smart and imaginative as the films they accompany."
Godfrey Cheshire, New York Press |
"The score (to Lonesome) by the Alloy Orchestra,
a three-man group that creates amazing sounds from offbeat percussion instruments
and synthesizers, augments Fejos's edgy, jagged lyricism."
The New Yorker |
"The Alloy Orchestra will play along to the 1929
classic with their racks of junk metal and a keyboard made of doorbells,
giving Lonesome a modern voice box. The effect is spellbinding."
Time
Out, New York |
| "The Alloy's original music for Lonesome thunders
along with their customary displays of exhilarating rhythm, but also weaves
original motifs together with the film's Irving Berlin theme song, "Always,"
creating a score more melodically satisfying than anything else they've
done." Jason Vince, Village Voice |
| "If more silent movies had received a live accompaniment
from the Alloy Orchestra those new-fangled talkies might never have taken
off. "
Bruce Stirling, The Dominion (New Zealand) |
"The Alloy Orchestra's second stunning performance
found the threesome playing the score to The Man with the Movie Camera,
and the result left the audience reeling, ecstatic, and utterly gobsmacked."
The Dominion (New Zealand) |
"The three-man ensemble's original score (for Man
with a Movie Camera) - a syncopated noise symphony that, at once homemade
and high-tech, mixes radio transmissions, birdcalls, and police sirens-
surpasses all expectations in its sensitivity to Vertov's wit, eccentricity,
and sense of rhythm. ...A once-in-a-life-time experience."
J. Hoberman, Village Voice |
"When I heard the Cambridge, Massachusetts-based
Alloy Orchestra play their rich score for the German "Sylvester" at the
Telluride Film Festival in Colorado, their dynamism galvanized an overflow
audience into cheers."
Kenneth Turan, Smithsonian Magazine |
| "(The Man with a Movie Camera) is a gem, a landmark,
a cause for celebration. But when the three man Alloy Orchestra performs
its complementary score, "Man" moves onto an even higher plane: an event
that defines the wonders of sight and sound. ... Add in that phenomenal
score, which stops only when the action does, and "Man with a Movie Camera"
emerges as one of the year's filmgoing highlights, a must for all movie-
and music- lovers alike. "
Larry Worth, New York Post |
| "One of the greatest silents, Victor Seastrom's
"The Wind" (1928), will screen tonight with live accompaniment by the Alloy
Orchestra. Its soaring, pulsating score complements the visual splendor
and psychological complexity of this terse, succinct story."
Los Angeles
Times |
"The amazingly versatile sounds of the Alloy trio
manage to convey just the right mood - electronic surges, lurching percussion
syncopations: at times like a calliope, at others like a brass band; land
sometimes, during the long sequence at Coney Island, switching from dance-band
fox trots to desert-caravan strains. With the remarkable impressionistic
ad-lib accompaniment by Alloy backing the mesmerizing visual and dramatic
concepts of Fejos' "Lonesome" emerges as an unequaled capturing of life,
love and survival-in-the-city during the late 1920's."
Philip Elwood, San
Francisco Examiner |
"If I had to pick a single favorite program
at Telluride ) it would have been the restored version of the 1929 quasi-silent
film ÒLonesomeÓ which was accompanied live by the Alloy Orchestra."
Roger Ebert, Chicago Sun-Times |
"The Alloy Orchestra constituted the event
of the Telluride festival. They crashed cymbals, beat on all sorts of metallic
devices, added a piano and accordion and left the crowd limp at the end."
Howie Movshovitz, Denver Post |
"Of the revivals, a standout
was Paul FejosÕs poignantly poetic 1928 silent, "Lonesome,"
with extraordinary accompaniment by the unique Alloy Orchestra."
Todd McCarthy, Daily Variety
|
| "Another audience-pleaser was the return appearance
of the Alloy Orchestra, the Cambridge, Mass.-based trio who compose and
play original scores to accompany vintage silent films. This yearÕs discovery
was the 1928 "Lonesome," by Paul Fejos, a winsome tale of love
between two lost souls in the big city, made all the more charming by the
hand-painted color sequences of Coney Island and by the brilliant cacophony
created by the orchestra."
Anne Hurley, Los Angeles Times |
(The Alloy Orchestra) "Is widely considered
to form the premier silent-movie band."
Bob Young, Boston Herald |
 |